Cherry Grove Pizza Menu

Right in the heart of Fire Island, just steps from the beach at 179 Ocean Walk, the Cherry Grove Pizza Menu feels like exactly what you want after a long, sunny day. It’s the kind of place where you can smell the dough baking before you even step inside, and once you look over the menu, it’s hard to choose just one thing. Of course, the classic slices are front and center - crisp crust, gooey cheese, and that perfect balance of sauce - but there’s plenty more to explore.

From specialty pies loaded with fresh toppings to hearty heroes and casual sides that are easy to share, everything feels laid-back and satisfying. Whether you’re grabbing a quick slice in flip-flops or settling in with friends for a full pie, the options are simple, familiar, and exactly what a beach town craving calls for.